Softball and soccer players who play sports year-round will want to interchange their cleats for each sport. Buying expensive cleats each season can become costly for players. Soccer and softball players may be able to save money on cleats.
The difference between softball cleats and soccer cleats is the metal spikes. Metal spikes are not allowed in soccer games, only plastic spikes.
We’re going to break down the difference between softball and soccer cleats and how you can save money.
What’s The Difference Between Softball & Soccer Cleats?
Softball Cleats
Softball cleats and soccer cleats are a bit different in style but essentially serve the same purpose, to provide traction to the athlete to generate force from the ground up.
Softball cleats are designed to have longer spikes outside the foot, as players will often be using hip torque to hit and throw the ball.
Above is a women’s Mizuno fastpitch softball cleat. As you can see, the spikes are evenly distributed throughout the cleat. As players step, whether in the batter’s box or throwing the ball, we want the front foot to pivot to make an effective throw. The even distribution of the spikes will help generate power from the ground.
Softball cleats are designed with the athlete in mind. Another major difference is the metal spikes instead of the plastic round spikes. Metal is great for a few reasons:
- Digs deeper into the ground for better traction on certain surfaces
- The cleats stay more rigid than plastic for a more extended period. Plastic will wear down and sometimes snap off if a considerable amount of contact is made.
- Players will feel more bounce on an elevated surface, helping them propel off the mound when pitching.
Below is a video of a former AAA pitcher talking about his experience with metal vs. molded cleats
Softball cleats with metal spikes have been great for athletes consistently walking on the hardtops. Dugouts, on-deck circles, and bullpens often have concrete surfaces near the bench.
Using molded cleats on this surface will consistently scuff the plastic mold and wear down the overall value of the cleats. Cleats that don’t provide efficient traction are useless for the athlete.
Soccer Cleats
Soccer cleats differ from softball cleats due to their mobility. As mentioned above, the spikes on the cleat are entirely different. For a visual reference, here’s what a soccer cleat looks like:
The Women’s Adidas Goletto VI FG W cleat is an excellent example of why this cleat is necessary for soccer. If we look at the bottom of the cleat, we can see how all the spikes are molded and are mostly placed on the exterior of the cleat.
Soccer consists of constant starting, stopping, and cutting. Having spikes evenly placed throughout the cleat will cause too much traction. Too much traction isn’t always an excellent thing for soccer players. Consistent stress on their knees throughout a game can have long-term implications.
Especially now with the artificial surfaces, we never want a cleat to get stuck in the ground. The bottom of the cleat shown above demonstrates why a soccer cleat is made specifically for soccer. A softball player, when batting, opens their front toe and spins off the back foot to swing the bat.
Having too much traction on the outside of the foot will slow down the hip torque and not allow proper swing speed.
For this reason alone, we recommend having two different cleats for two other sports.
Wearing Metal Cleats For Soccer
Sports like soccer, football, and other semi-contact sports permit metal cleats for injury purposes.
For example, slide tackling an opponent is a great way to steal the ball from an opponent. Plastic hitting the skin vs. metal hitting the skin are two different types of contact. One will leave a bruise, and one can draw blood.
It’s essential to check with your league director to see if it’s permitted to wear cleats. Some leagues may allow it, but plastic cleats are the best option for soccer for the most part.
See Our Complete List Of Helpful Soccer Articles Here.
Metal Or Plastic Cleats?
We laid out a good amount of the differences between metal and plastic cleats. There are pros to both metal and plastic spikes, in our expert opinion.
Metal Cleats
As mentioned, metal cleats typically tend to last longer than plastic spikes. When plastic spikes are consistently walked on pavement or concrete, they will be scraped down to nothing.
Metal Spikes last longer because they’re more rigid and can withstand the consistent rattling of concrete. Metal spikes are also more evenly distributed throughout the foot to give a more balanced feel throughout the shoe.
The downside of the metal spikes is they can be used in a few sports, mainly softball. Other sports don’t allow the use of metal spikes, so if you’re looking for a seasonal cleat and don’t mind spending the money, the metal cleats are a great option.
Plastic Cleats
Plastic bottomed cleats are well-rounded for all sports. If you’re looking for the best buying option, plastic bottom cleats are the best bet.
They tend to wear down the more they’re worn on hard surfaces and in general. One benefit of getting plastic cleats is getting removable spikes. These spikes can be purchased, and new cleats can quickly be replenished to full traction in minutes.
This gives the player the option to change out the cleats once the original plastic has been worn down.
Most players will opt for molded cleats, which brings us to the downside of the plastic bottom cleats. Once they are worn down, the cleats are essentially useless. Sports like soccer will play in the rain/mud and disregard weather conditions. This will have a tremendous impact on the longevity of the cleats.
Summer sports like softball will cancel games if it’s raining, so these cleats also tend to last longer. Be cautious of how harsh the weather conditions are if you purchase molded cleats and how often you’ll have to buy new cleats.
Best Cleats For Both Soccer & Softball
If you’re looking for a cleat for both soccer and softball, we’ve found some available options that will help you in your decision-making. There are a few key points we looked at when building our list:
- Price Points – The most important factor, as we’re all not made of money
- Type – We’re going to provide both metal and plastic options. This way, you’ll be able to decide whatever cleat best fits your situation
- Overall Comfort and Longevity
Mizuno Women’s 9-Spike Advanced Sweep 3
The shoe is priced anywhere from $45 and on. What’s great about this shoe is it has Wave technology which provides cushioning and stability to the foot. It weighs 10.1 oz which is pretty light for a cheaper cleat.
It also has six different color schemes, including red, white, blue, and green. This is a great cleat if you’re not looking to break the bank.
Check out the shoe here with purchasing options.
New Balance Women’s Velo V1 Metal Softball Shoe
The new balance Velo V1 is great because, for those who know how comfortable New Balance shoes are, the cleat is just as comfortable. This cleat has a fresh foam insole that is comfortable to wear before, during, and after the game.
The cleat is pretty pricey at $90 compared to our previous shoe, but if you’re concerned about comfort and have a durable shoe, you can never go wrong with New Balance.
The New Balance Velo V1 can be found here on Amazon.
Nike Women’s Hyperdiamond 2.5 Keystone
This plastic molded shoe is great for a dual-purpose cleat. If you’re looking to wear this during softball and soccer, you’ll be able to get multi-use from this style of the cleat.
Made from synthetic leather and TPU mesh, it has supreme durability. The stylish cleat also comes in 2 other designs, including a flashy red design. The clean varies from $30 all the way to $90, depending on size.
Shop the Nike Hyperdiamond here on Amazon
Adidas Women’s Icon Bounce TPU
The Adidas Women’s Icon Bounce TPU is a textile and synthetic cleat with bounce cushioning that provides comfort and flexibility throughout the game.
The cleat is great for multi-purpose use and is built to handle any position on the field. The Women’s Icon Bounce TPU can be found here on Amazon.
Conclusion
Can you play softball with soccer cleats? Yes, you can. However, if you’re looking to maximize your performance and keep the longevity of the cleat (at least a year), it’s best to have different cleats for different sports.
This will ultimately help save your wallet and keep the cleat as conditioned as possible for the entire season. Purchasing multiple cleats as a player gets older is mandatory; however, making smart decisions by buying a multi-purpose cleat can help in the long run.